Feedback is the process of providing constructive and timely information to the project team members about their performance, behaviour, and contribution to the project. Feedback can help the project team to improve their skills, knowledge, and motivation, and to achieve the project goals and deliverables. According to the Project Management Professional (PMP) Reference Materials1, feedback can be given in various ways, such as:
Formal or informal: Formal feedback is planned and structured, and follows a specific format, criteria, and frequency. Informal feedback is spontaneous and flexible, and does not follow a predefined format or schedule.
Positive or negative: Positive feedback is praise or recognition for doing something well, and aims to reinforce and encourage the desired performance or behaviour. Negative feedback is criticism or correction for doing something poorly, and aims to address and improve the undesired performance or behaviour.
Individual or group: Individual feedback is given to one person at a time, and focuses on their specific performance or behaviour. Group feedback is given to a team or a group of people at the same time, and focuses on their collective performance or behaviour.
In this scenario, the team is working on a critical project deliverable and the project manager is concerned about meeting the deadline. There have been complaints from some stakeholders about some of the team members’ performance. The project manager wants to understand the situation and provide feedback to the team as soon as possible. Therefore, the best three actions that the project manager should take to address this situation are:
Define team ground rules: Team ground rules are the agreed-upon norms and expectations that guide the team’s work and interactions. They can help the team to establish a common vision, purpose, and values, and to define their roles, responsibilities, and accountabilities. They can also help the team to communicate effectively, collaborate efficiently, and resolve conflicts constructively. By defining team ground rules, the project manager can ensure that the team members are aware of and aligned with the project goals and deliverables, and that they respect and support each other’s performance and behaviour.
Perform a retrospective session: A retrospective session is a meeting that allows the team to reflect on their past performance and behaviour, and to identify what went well, what went wrong, and what can be improved. It can help the team to learn from their experiences, celebrate their achievements, and address their challenges. It can also help the team to generate ideas and action plans for future improvement and innovation. By performing a retrospective session, the project manager can provide formal and group feedback to the team, and involve them in the feedback process.
Implement daily team meetings: Daily team meetings are short and frequent meetings that allow the team to share their progress, issues, and plans for the day. They can help the team to stay on track, coordinate their tasks, and solve their problems. They can also help the team to communicate regularly, transparently, and collaboratively. By implementing daily team meetings, the project manager can provide informal and individual feedback to the team members, and monitor and support their performance and behaviour.
The other options are not the best choices, because:
Request a manager performance review: A manager performance review is a formal and individual feedback that is given by the team member’s direct manager, and focuses on their overall performance, behaviour, and career development. It is usually done annually or semi-annually, and follows a specific format and criteria. While a manager performance review can be useful and beneficial for the team member, it is not the responsibility of the project manager, unless they are also the team member’s direct manager. Moreover, it is not the most appropriate or timely feedback for the situation, as it does not address the specific project deliverable, deadline, or stakeholder complaints.
Conduct an annual review: An annual review is a formal and group feedback that is given by the project manager, and focuses on the team’s overall performance, behaviour, and achievements for the year. It is usually done at the end of the year or the project, and follows a specific format and criteria. While an annual review can be useful and beneficial for the team, it is not the most appropriate or timely feedback for the situation, as it does not address the specific project deliverable, deadline, or stakeholder complaints.
