Comprehensive and Detailed in Depth Explanation:
In HashiCorp Vault, authentication methods (auth methods) are mechanisms that allow users or machines to authenticate and obtain a token. When an auth method like userpass is enabled, it is mounted at a specific path in Vault’s namespace, and this path determines where operators interact with it—e.g., to log in, configure, or manage it.
The userpass auth method is enabled with the command vault auth enable -path=users userpass, meaning it’s explicitly mounted at the users/ path. However, Vault’s authentication system has a standard convention: all auth methods are accessed under the auth/ prefix, followed by the mount path. This prefix is a logical namespace separating authentication endpoints from secrets engines or system endpoints.
Option A: users/auth/This reverses the expected order. The auth/ prefix comes first, followed by the mount path (users/), not the other way around. This path would not correspond to any valid Vault endpoint for interacting with the userpass auth method. Incorrect.
Option B: authentication/usersVault does not use authentication/ as a prefix; it uses auth/. The term “authentication” is not part of Vault’s path structure—it’s a conceptual term, not a literal endpoint. This makes the path invalid and unusable in Vault’s API or CLI. Incorrect.
Option C: auth/usersThis follows Vault’s standard convention: auth/ (the authentication namespace) followed by users (the custom mount path specified when enabling the auth method). For example, to log in using the userpass method mounted at users/, the command would be vault login -method=userpass -path=users username=. The API endpoint would be /v1/auth/users/login. This is the correct path for operators to interact with the auth method, whether via CLI, UI, or API. Correct.
Option D: users/While users/ is the mount path, omitting the auth/ prefix breaks Vault’s structure. Directly accessing users/ would imply it’s a secrets engine or other mount type, not an auth method. Auth methods always require the auth/ prefix for interaction. Incorrect.
Detailed Mechanics:
When an auth method is enabled, Vault creates a backend at the specified path under auth/. The userpass method, for instance, supports endpoints like /login (for authentication) and /users/ (for managing users). If mounted at users/, these become auth/users/login and auth/users/users/. This structure ensures isolation and clarity in Vault’s routing system. The ability to customize the path (e.g., users/ instead of the default userpass/) allows flexibility for organizations with multiple auth instances, but the auth/ prefix remains mandatory.
Overall Explanation from Vault Docs:
“When enabled, auth methods are mounted within the Vault mount table under the auth/ prefix… For example, enabling userpass at users/ allows interaction at auth/users.” This convention ensures operators can consistently locate and manage auth methods, regardless of custom paths.
[Reference:https://developer.hashicorp.com/vault/docs/auth#enabling-disabling-auth-methods, ]
