A 22-year-old patient fell and had pain in their right arm.

The correct answer is B. Causation.

Negligence in EMS requires four elements:

Duty to act

Breach of duty

Causation

Damages

Why B is correct (Causation):

Causation refers to:

A direct link between the EMT’s actions (or inaction) and the patient’s injury or worsening condition

In this scenario:

The EMT failed to splint the arm

During transport, the injury worsened (deformity developed)

The patient required surgical intervention

This demonstrates that the EMT’s action (not splinting) directly caused further harm, which defines causation.

NREMT-aligned references state:

“Causation means that the provider’s actions directly caused the patient’s injury.”

Why the other options are incorrect:

A. DamagesRefers to the actual harm or injury suffered (which is present, but the question focuses on the link between action and outcome)

C. Duty to actRefers to the EMT’s responsibility to provide care (already assumed in this scenario)

D. Breach of dutyRefers to failure to meet the standard of care (also present, but the question specifically highlights the resulting worsening condition, pointing to causation)

Exact Extracts (NREMT-aligned EMT educational references):

“Negligence requires duty to act, breach of duty, causation, and damages.”

“Causation links the provider’s actions to the patient’s injury.”

“Failure to provide appropriate care that results in harm establishes causation.”

Clinical Priority Summary:

Because the EMT’s failure to splint directly led to worsening injury and need for surgery, this scenario best illustrates causation, making B the correct answer.